Follow Us on Social Media

Can You Freeze Butter? How Long It Lasts & How to Thaw It

Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Email
Print
Threads

In Short

Yes, you can freeze butter, and it freezes very well. Keep it in its original wrapper and add foil or a freezer bag to block odors. Use salted butter within about 9 months and unsalted within 5 for the best flavor. Thaw it overnight in the fridge, or grate it frozen straight into pie dough or biscuits.

Butter is mostly fat with very little water, which is why it handles the freezer so much better than milk or cream cheese.

can you freeze butter

How Long Can You Freeze Butter?

Here's the catch: page one of Google can't agree on a number.

These are each source's own freezer times for best quality:

Source Salted butter Unsalted butter
Land O'Lakes up to 4 months up to 4 months
U.S. Dairy up to 9 months up to 5 months
National Center for Home Food Preservation 6 to 9 months 6 to 9 months
University of Illinois Extension 12 months 12 months

They differ because these are quality windows, not safety limits.

Illinois Extension says food kept frozen at 0°F stays safe as long as it hasn't thawed.

I recommend the middle of the pack, which is the U.S. Dairy guideline: 9 months for salted, 5 for unsalted.

After that, the butter is still safe, but the flavor starts to fade.

Salted vs. Unsalted

Both freeze well. Salted just keeps its flavor longer.

North Dakota State University Extension notes that unsalted butter loses flavor, so its storage time is shorter.

If you bake with unsalted, put new boxes in the back and use the oldest first.

How to Freeze Butter

Butter soaks up smells. Nobody wants shortbread that tastes like frozen fish.

  1. Keep the original wrapper on. That paper or foil is your first layer.
  2. Add a second layer. NDSU Extension says to over-wrap the store wrap with freezer wrap. Foil, plastic wrap, or the original box works.
  3. Bag it. Slide everything into a zip-top freezer bag and press out the air.
  4. Label it with the date and salted or unsalted.
  5. Store it away from strong smells like onions, fish, and garlic bread.

To freeze it pre-portioned, my butter measurement guide shows how to cut sticks into tablespoons or cups first.

Brown Butter, Compound Butter, and Whipped Butter

Flavored butter freezes well, per NDSU Extension.

Roll compound butter into a log in plastic wrap, then slice off rounds as you need them.

Herb compound butter rolled into a log in plastic wrap with rounds sliced off for freezing

Brown butter freezes the same way. Cool it, pour it into a small container or ice cube tray, and freeze in portions. That's handy for my brown butter oatmeal cookies.

Whipped butter and tubs are the exception.

NDSU says whipped butter doesn't freeze well because the emulsion can break and separate.

How to Thaw Frozen Butter Fast

Most cookie and cake recipes want softened butter.

Here's how to get there, from slowest to fastest.

  • Overnight in the fridge: NDSU Extension says to thaw frozen dairy in the refrigerator. Move a stick down the night before, then let it soften on the counter.
  • Grate it: Run the frozen stick over the large holes of a box grater. The shreds soften in minutes.
  • Cube it: Cut it into small pieces and spread them on a plate. More surface means faster softening.
  • Microwave, carefully: Use the defrost setting in very short bursts and turn the stick each time.

Melted spots change how butter creams with sugar, which can mean flat cookies. That's why the microwave is my last pick.

My guide to room temperature butter for baking shows what "softened" should feel like.

Baking With Butter Straight From Frozen

Some recipes want butter as cold as it gets.

Cold butter makes little pockets of steam in the oven, and that's what gives you flaky layers.

  • Pie crust: Grate frozen butter into the flour. It mixes in fast without warming up in your hands.
  • Biscuits and scones: Same trick. My cheese scones depend on very cold butter for tender layers.
  • Crumble and streusel: Frozen butter keeps the crumbs chunky instead of pasty. Try it in the crumb base of my strawberry shortcake bars.

The best part? You skip the "chill the butter" step entirely.

How to Tell If Frozen Butter Has Gone Bad

Well-wrapped butter rarely goes bad in the freezer. It just loses flavor over time.

Watch for these signs:

  • Dry, pale, or darker patches on the surface (freezer burn)
  • An off, sour, or stale smell
  • A taste like the rest of your freezer

Stick of freezer-burned butter with pale dry edges next to a fresh stick

If only the outer edge looks dry, trim it off.

If the whole stick smells strange, toss it.

Stacie's Tricks & Tips

  • Freeze it before the date: Freeze butter while it's fresh, not when it's about to expire.
  • Double wrap, every time: The paper wrapper alone won't stop freezer smells.
  • Keep a grater handy: Grated frozen butter is the fastest way to soften it and the best way to bake with it.
  • Rotate unsalted first: It loses flavor sooner.
  • Freeze leftover buttercream too: Press plastic wrap on the surface, thaw it in the fridge, and re-whip it. My buttercream frosting comes right back.

Next time butter goes on sale, grab a few extra boxes. A frozen stock means cheese scones are always one grater away.

For a professional bakery look with easy cleanup, Caraway Home is my go-to choice. Grab yours here and use code STACIE for a festive saving!

For more easy recipe tutorials and expert baking tips, subscribe to Sugar Face Bakes on YouTube and join our growing community of home bakers!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you freeze butter in its original packaging?

Yes, but add a second layer. The paper or foil wrapper alone doesn't block freezer odors, and butter soaks up smells fast. Wrap it in foil or plastic, or keep it in the box, then slide it into a zip-top freezer bag. Press out the air and label it with the date and salted or unsalted.

No, it's better not to. NDSU Extension says not to refreeze thawed dairy, and each round of freezing dulls the flavor. Move one stick at a time to the fridge so you only thaw what you'll use. Cutting sticks into tablespoons before freezing makes that even easier.

No. For pie crust and biscuits, grate it straight from the freezer into the flour, since cold butter makes the steam pockets behind flaky layers. For creamed cookies and cakes, soften it first. Move it to the fridge the night before, or grate or cube it to soften it in minutes.

Stick margarine, yes, but skip the tubs. Illinois Extension lists butter and margarine together at 12 months in the freezer. NDSU Extension says whipped butter and margarine don't freeze well because they can separate. I recommend freezing stick margarine only, double-wrapped like butter, and using it in baking.

Yes, if it was wrapped well. Thawed butter creams and bakes like fresh, as long as it softens without melted spots. Melted spots change how butter creams with sugar, which can mean flat cookies. Freezer odors are the only other real problem, so double wrap it every time.

More Cooking Recipes

Picture of Stacie

Stacie

Hello out there! My name is Stacie.

I'm a home baker whose guilty pleasure is homemade food and desserts. My blog is for the non-professionals, the at-home bakers and cooks, lovers of desserts, and anyone who desires delicious food right from home.

For daily recipes delivered straight to your inbox, sign up now!

Nothing is better than a homemade meal or dessert made from scratch, except the reward when the whole dish is devoured by your guests. Questions, comments, idea are all welcomed!

Sign Up Here!

LATEST Recipes

Copycat Olive Garden salad, Italian salad with lettuce, tomatoes, pepperoncini, olives, croutons, and Parmesan

Copycat Olive Garden Salad

Copycat Starbucks egg bites, bacon and Gruyère bites with crispy bacon, melted cheese, and a creamy center

Copycat Starbucks Egg Bites

Chick fil A sauce with a crispy homemade chicken nugget on a fork dipped in the creamy golden sauce

Copycat Chick-fil-A Sauce

Copycat Chick-fil-A nuggets, close-up of a crispy nugget on a fork showing juicy white chicken inside

Copycat Chick-fil-A Chicken Nuggets

Copycat Olive Garden Alfredo sauce, creamy and dripping from a spoon into a saucepan

Copycat Olive Garden Alfredo Sauce

Copycat Chick-fil-A mac and cheese, baked in a ceramic dish with creamy cheddar sauce and a golden-brown cheese top

Copycat Chick-fil-A Mac and Cheese